Reality Bytes: Is Equal Opportunity Just A Myth?

Equal Opportunity Just A Myth?

Is Equal Opportunity Just a Myth?

America claims to be dedicated to
equal opportunity, yet equality is not sufficient in urban communities. These
kids need more. We need to think about equity, not equality. It is not enough to
hide them away. These are visions we should never

Link to full text: View
more »

In Amazing Grace: The lives of children and the
conscience of a nation, Jonathan Kozol paints a vivid picture of the conditions
in the poorest sections of New York City. During the early to mid 1990’s, Kozol
made several visits to Mott Haven in the South Bronx. As he describes in Amazing
Grace, the South Bronx is one of the most severely segregated and poorest
Congressional Districts in the United States.
The members of this community have been segregated into a
hell plagued with sickness, violence and despair. Kozol argues that this
strategic placement serves to isolate the rich from the realities they have
thrust upon their fellow man. New Yorkers do not stroll through the streets of
Mott Haven, and taxicabs take no short cuts through Beekman Avenue. Many
taxicabs will not even venture past East 96th Street. Out of sight is out of

As I was reading Amazing Grace, I remember thinking back to my days
living in Manhattan, coincidentally around the same time Kozol conducted his
interviews in the South Bronx. I lived in what Kozol refers to as Manhattan’s
“Liberal West Side,” an area that was undergoing rapid transformation and
gentrification at the time Mayor Rudolph Giuliani took office.

There is
no excuse for the conditions in which these people must live. No person should
be forced into an apartment that has a higher ratio of cockroaches and rats than
human beings.

In 1995, the American Sociological Association (ASA) held
its annual conference in New York City. Prior to that meeting, they sent out a
fact sheet that may be of interest to ASA members. In this sheet, they too
described the same social conditions and asked their members to take note of the
changes that occur at 96th Street. I can assure you that the conditions Kozol
describes in his book were not exaggerated.

These children are
desperately in need of the best schools, yet we give them the worst. They have
few libraries, few safe havens, few doctors, and few role models. They have
every reason to believe that they are throwaway children and we have certainly
not shown them anything else. The social services we have provided are a
bureaucratic nightmare. People in need are treated as sub-human, and made to
feel ashamed of being poor.

These are among the sickest children in the
world. Americans claim to be dedicated to the children and fool ourselves into
believing that we are doing them a favor by providing them with medical care,
public education, and public housing. Yet, the quality of their neighborhoods
speaks volumes of our sentiment and intentions.

Shortly after Amazing
Grace was published, managed care rapidly moved onto the New York scene. Around
the same time, the Mayor announced he would be closing some of the hospitals
that served the poorest of the poor because of financial problems associated
with payment and large trauma departments.

Kozol makes the point that
people could attempt to gain admissions at a better hospital than Bronx-Lebanon;
yet, the privatization of Medicaid has now made this completely impossible.
Further restrictions on medical care are inevitable as the result of Medicaid
managed care. The law is not designed to protect these people, and this was made
obvious in a recent conversation I had with a friend who practices medicine in
New York.

My friend John works as a board certified trauma physician at a
private hospital on the Upper East Side. The last black patient he treated at
Beth Israel was famed rock singer Michael Jackson. I asked him if he ever gets
any asthma patients in his ER. He knew immediately of whom I was speaking. “You
mean the kids from the South Bronx?” he asked. He told me that they know better
than to show up at Beth Israel. “But if they do?” I asked, and he replied, “We
ship them back.”

This is the reality. The best doctors treat the
wealthiest patients rather than the sickest. Schools educate the best students
rather than the neediest. It is no wonder that these children perform poorly in
school. By every measure, these children are destined for failure. Their home
life is less than enchanting, and they do not benefit from enriched environments
and educated parents.

Certainly, there are many dedicated parents who
care about their children, but is that enough? When I was in school, children
frequently asked the teacher, how will this help later in life. In my class,
there was an unequivocal reply, but it could be argued that what children in the
South Bronx need to learn couldn’t be taught in the classroom.

There is
no doubt that the prevalence of violence in urban neighborhoods affects the
ability of children to perform well in school. There is a large body of
empirical evidence that demonstrates the effects of chronic stress on memory and
the learning process. Rather than taking the children out of these communities,
we have constructed prison like buildings for them to attend school. They
routinely have gunfire drills reminding them that danger is never far

Children cannot learn in this environment. This constant stress
triggers “hot-memory.” Hot memory can be thought of as learning with your heart
and not your mind. It is no wonder children perform inadequately in this

It is bad enough that children live in such conditions, must
we educate in them too? If we want underprivileged children to learn and grow
spiritually, we must create an environment that allows their cool memory systems
to take over.

It is only under these conditions that children will permit
themselves to learn and develop their intellectual strengths. We have failed to
create a safe home environment for urban children, but we can give serious
thought to creating a school environment outside of the community so they have
fewer fear-driven hours each day.

Studies consistently report lower
academic achievement in urban neighborhoods like Mott Haven in the South Bronx.
Children growing up in urban neighborhoods have a much higher incidence of
posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Most researchers believe this to be the
direct result of living in stressed communities plagued with street crime and
violence. The potential impact of chronic stress on academic performance and
achievement is not known, but reading scores in neighborhoods like Mott Haven
certainly seem to indicate some type of causal relationship. There is virtually
no research on looking at the long-term effects of this inflated incidence of
PTSD among urban populations. It is important to develop an understanding of the
effects of fear on the academic performance of urban adolescents so we can begin
to dismantle the myths regarding school performance and minority

Under these conditions, it is not surprising to learn that
students also report pervasive feelings of fear and do not feel secure despite
the added presence of security personnel on school grounds. For these students,
school is a mere extension of the violent communities in which they

Since urban communities have many different sources of stress, it
is important to examine how school policies contribute to the learning
environment in public schools. The quick response has been to install weapons
detectors and hire school security for urban schools. The presence of school
security certainly affects the climate of American public schools by
establishing school environments that focus more on student behavior than
student achievement. Together, the urban public school and the community it
serves are a constant reminder of the poor living conditions and social reality
of urban America.

The secured environment is an indication of the roles
students are expected to play later in life. This is a lesson they will not soon

Kozol makes it quite clear that there are several exceptional
children in this community. There are probably as many exceptional children here
as every other community around the country, yet, so few of them will make it
out of the South Bronx. Kozol is careful not to dwell on the exceptional cases
of children who successfully navigate their way into the main stream of society.
Kozol does this so we do not develop a false sense of hope. If we cling to a few
exceptional cases, we may come to believe that what we are giving enough to
children like Anthony or Anabelle. Clearly, we can do more. Failure should be
the exception—not the rule. Success should be the norm, and until it is, we
should not give up hope for these children.

America claims to be
dedicated to equal opportunity, yet equality is not sufficient in a community
like Mott Haven. These kids need more. We need to think about equity, not
equality. It is not enough to hide them away. These are visions we should never

Welcome to America. The Wealthiest Nation in the

Reference: Amazing Grace: The lives of children and
the conscience of a nation. (by Jonathan Kozol)

to the assholes who made fortune off this piece……


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s